Rambling Ever On Revisits “Independence Day”

Summer of 1996. It was an incredibly monumental time in my life. I had just finished my Freshman year in college. I would meet my future wife that summer at a St. Louis Cardinals’ baseball game. And, though not as important in the grand scheme of life, I would watch Independence Day in a packed theater in St. Louis.

Before we dive in to my most recent viewing of the film, it might help to set the stage with a little contextual color, as it were. By that summer, I had seen a decent number of films on the big screen, as it was one of my favorite activities my first year in college. (I do sincerely apologize to the good people at Welch College for violating the “no movie theater” policy many times throughout my time there.) Yet, even though I had seen any number of films before Independence Day, my experience in that theater was something spectacularly transformative.

Independence Day Destruction

The theater was packed. The trailer for the film had done an amazing job of selling the film and preparing the audience for a good time. And the film delivered in every way. The audience cheered, clapped, yelled, and stood on their feet during the showing. Spoiler alert: when the film pans across the wake of destruction left by the initial alien attack and we see the destroyed Statue of Liberty, the audience was so invested and angry, I was certain an all-out brawl was about to break out. Needless to say, it was an amazing theater experience and one I have longed to relive many times.

Fast forward a few decades…

Independence Day is not high art. It was not an Academy Award hopeful, outside of some of the technical aspects of the film, such as special effects. All that said, it was not panned by critics; it stands at 67% on Rotten Tomatoes – which is enough to earn a “Fresh” rating. The audience for the film was the general audience. I realize that sounds redundant but there are many films made with very little concern for how the average filmgoer will react to it. First and foremost, Independence Day was a crowd-pleaser, earning over $300 million at the domestic box office.

Independence Day Strut

The film is turning 25 this summer, so I decided to rewatch it after quite a few years since my last viewing. While I can’t say the film hit me the same way as it did when I was 18 years old, I still very much enjoyed it. If you are expecting a mature, emotionally complex take on an alien invasion, disaster film, Independence Day is not it. Though, I do wonder why anyone would look for those things in an alien invasion movie. But, if you want good action, fun characters, and a relentlessly paced plot, this film still works just fine.

It’s the people that matter.

The film still works as well as it does because the cast is perfectly suited for their roles. Will Smith became a worldwide superstar due to this film and he absolutely earns it. He is charismatic, confident, and delivers his lines with the appropriate level of cocky charm. Jeff Goldblum is exactly what you expect from him: witty, funny, and quirky. But for me, the true star of the film is Bill Pullman as President Thomas Whitmore. Pullman is not and has never been an action hero type actor. He’s a character actor. And while he is not exactly action hero level in this film, he has his moments. And if you can find a better Presidential speech in film history, point me to it.

Independence Day Speech

Yes, there are head-scratching plot points. And yes, defeating the aliens with a computer virus is dumb. But, none of those things matter if you take the film for what it is. Don’t overanalyze it. Don’t overthink it. Settle in for a fun, sort of dumb, exciting two hours and fifteen minutes and that is exactly what you’ll get. I’ve long contended that you have to take art of any sort in the manner in which it is intended to be appreciated. Independence Day is fun and that is all it wants to be. Even after 25 years it still entertains. I can’t ask for anything more.

Content warning: The film is rated PG-13 and it earns that rating. Proceed with caution.

Phill Lytle

I love Jesus, my wife, my kids, my family, my friends, my church, J.R.R. Tolkien, C.S. Lewis, 80s rock, the Tennessee Titans, Brandon Sanderson books, Band of Brothers, Thai food, music, books, movies, TV, writing, pizza, vacation, etc...

2 thoughts on “Rambling Ever On Revisits “Independence Day”

  • April 7, 2021 at 1:45 pm

    Good read, Philip. I totally agree, having watched the film many times over the years. I also read the prequel novel, “The Silent Zone” detailing Dr. Okun’s early years and subsequent appointment to Area 51, and “The Crucible”, which was set between the first & second films, and feel like both add a lot to the story. If you haven’t seen the sequel, I recommend reading “The Crucible” first. It gives a lot of information they leak out over the course of the film that helps better set the stage and informs how certain characters interact.

    There are a few other actors who are perfectly suited to their characters, Brent Spiner as Dr. Okun and Randy Quaid as Russell Casse being two of them. Having been a huge Star Trek: TNG fan since it first entered syndication, it was nice to see Brent have a very different role, which he turned in marvelously as the mad scientist (the scene where he asks if they want to see the alien bodies from the Roswell crash–especially his facial expressions–makes me laugh every time). Randy Quaid basically played Cousin Eddie from the National Lampoon movies, but his character was still spot-on.

    Did you see the extended version? It adds something like 16 minutes to the film and has an extended plotline about Casse and his step-children, but it also has a scene which I wish they had left in the theatrical release: Jeff Goldblum’s character goes into the alien ship and gets a good look around. They show a lot of the interior that you don’t get to see in the theatrical version, and I think that’s just a shame. There’s also a humorous exchange between Levinson & Okun where Okun tells Levinson not to touch anything (which Levinson promptly ignores once Okun leaves).

    Also, have you seen the sequel, “Resurgence”? I thought it was long overdue and a good chapter in the overall story. It’s too bad Will Smith refused to be in it, which they resolved by killing off his character.

    • April 7, 2021 at 3:59 pm

      Thanks for the response, Joel! I think you know more about this film, and the sequels/books, than anyone I know. I’ve only seen the original film. I haven’t read any of the connected books or seen the sequel, though I would like to see it at some point. I was disappointed that Will Smith did not return for it. That negatively affected my interest level in it.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.